1. Home
  2. News & Insights
  3. Critical Spare Parts and the Real Cost of Keeping Deck and Mooring Equipment Available

Industry note

Critical Spare Parts and the Real Cost of Keeping Deck and Mooring Equipment Available

A mooring winch that will not render, a windlass with a failed motor, or a deck crane held out of service can idle a berth, consume a dry-docking slot or delay a sailing. The purchase price of the failed component is usually a small fraction of what the vessel loses while the part is missing. This is the operational argument for treating critical spare parts as an availability problem rather than a purchasing line item, and it explains why research on maritime spares management is less about buying than about deciding where and when a part should be available. The rest of this article reviews what that research says about criticality, lead time, documentation and digital procurement, and what a technical buyer can reasonably ask a supplier's catalogue to provide.

The real cost of a part is measured in availability

Why acquisition price alone misleads

The total cost of ownership (TCO) argument is well established for long-life assets, although much of the formal modelling comes from outside marine engineering. A part TCO model developed for long-life-cycle electronic systems by Prabhakar & Sandborn (2012) addresses exactly the problem that initial part selection is often driven by procurement processes with little or no insight into the total cost of adopting and supporting a part, including obsolescence, reliability concerns and long-term supply-chain disruption. Their model was built to inform part selection and management decisions and to identify actions with the greatest future cost avoidance, and they demonstrate it on lifetime-buy and design-reuse cases for a surface-mount electronic component. The setting is different, but the reasoning transfers: a winch or a crane bought for a decade or more is acquired once and supported for years, and decisions that look cheapest at the order stage can be the most expensive over the support life.

For a technical buyer, the consequence is to price availability rather than hardware alone. Ask what the part's failure does to the vessel's schedule, what a stock-out would cost, and what the supplier can document about support life and obsolescence. A low unit price with a long, uncertain lead time is not cheap; it is a deferred cost with an unknown date.

Criticality is a classification decision, not an intuition

Not every part deserves the same treatment. Patzke, Saeed & Pahl (2024) use an ABC/XYZ analysis to categorise critical spare parts for vessels and entire fleets and to evaluate strategies for controlling them. ABC/XYZ is familiar inventory logic: ABC ranks items by importance or value, and XYZ ranks them by the predictability of demand. The authors' point is that the classification has to be made deliberately, because it determines what is held on board, what is held at a hub and what is ordered only when needed. Their analysis is based on a representative case in maritime bulk shipping, where port calls cannot be foreseen far in advance (they compare the setting to taxi driving), which makes the placement decision harder than in a fixed-route liner trade.

Spares decisions also interact with maintenance scheduling. Kian, Bektaş & Ouelhadj (2018) study a spare-part management problem for a vessel on a given sequence of port visits. Condition-based monitoring, used as part of predictive maintenance, collects real-time information on the health of machinery, allows a more accurate estimate of remaining life and provides warning of a potential failure; a failure then produces delays and downtime with associated cost and penalties. Their model decides when and to which port each part should be ordered, where the maintenance would also be performed, and it is formulated as a mathematical programme with a shortest-path dynamic programming solution for the single-part case, tested in simulation under different scenarios. The lesson for buyers is that deciding when to order is a scheduling question tied to where the ship will be, not a simple reorder point.

Critical or consumable: a working distinction

DimensionCritical partConsumable part
Failure consequenceStops or degrades a safety or operational functionGradual wear with planned replacement
Lead timeOften long, sometimes single-sourcedUsually short and widely stocked
Holding decisionHold on board, at a hub, or secure a contractual lead timeReorder on usage or at scheduled maintenance
DocumentationModel and serial specific, with drawing and traceabilityStandard specification with batch or lot reference
Buyer questionCan the supplier guarantee availability by a date?Can we simplify and consolidate the order?

The distinction is not permanent. Parts move between categories as a vessel ages, as a design is superseded or as a supplier's lead time changes, which is why classification should be reviewed rather than fixed once at delivery.

Digital procurement helps only when the data is usable

The case for digitalisation rests on a fairly simple observation: the maritime supply chain is geographically dispersed, and procurement depends on fast, accurate exchange of data between ship, shore office and supplier. A case study of e-procurement implementation at a ship management company (IRISL) makes this point in the shipping context and argues that moving from paper-based purchase processing to online procurement enables shipping lines to gain better procurement practices in terms of cost efficiency (Alipour & Damavandi, 2011).

More recent work shows what becomes possible when the data is captured at item level. Anglou, Ponis & Spanos (2021) propose a decision-support approach, using machine learning and operations research, to enable bulk ordering of spare parts for a fleet. Clustering is used to identify high-interest items, a forecasting tool estimates expected fleet needs and tests whether demand depends on the purchase source, and the selected items are then allocated cost-effectively across vendors. In a simulation of a bulk-order process on a mixed fleet totalling 75 vessels, the authors report a mean absolute percentage error of about 10% for specific components in their forecasting approach and a potential 9% overall cost reduction over two years from their cost optimiser. Those figures are specific to their simulation, not a promise for every fleet, but they show that the method depends on clean, item-level history. A portal on its own does not create that history.

The relationship dimension matters too. In a survey of 205 maritime logistics service players in Singapore, Shin, Thai & Yuen (2018) found that trust, as a component of supply-chain relationship quality, had a significant effect on supply-chain performance, while commitment did not in their analysis. The research agenda on shipbuilding also treats digitalisation and resilience as a joint subject: a 2023 empirical study in the Journal of Business Research is framed around a digital and resilient shipbuilding supply chain (Centobelli et al., 2023).

Documentation is the enabler

None of those methods works on anonymous parts. Classification needs item identity, forecasting needs history by part number, vendor allocation needs comparable specifications, and condition monitoring needs the correct component reference. This is where the product page and the spares list do more work than they are usually given credit for. A page that states the model range, materials, dimensions and supported variants becomes a usable spares reference; a page that states only a product family forces every replacement into a new enquiry cycle, with the vessel's schedule at the mercy of how quickly the supplier can identify the part.

The same information supports the buyer's own decisions. A mooring winch, windlass or deck crane page that gives the model designation, capacity, duty and material specification lets a purchaser build a spare-parts list around a known configuration rather than around a description. Where a page covers a specific configuration in detail, as with a two-drum hydraulic combined mooring winch, the part number, drawing reference and interchangeability information can be carried directly into the enquiry. That is the practical link between catalogue quality and supply-chain resilience: documentation makes the difference between a part that can be sourced and a part that has to be re-identified under time pressure.

A spare-parts enquiry checklist

A spare-parts enquiry is a different document from a new-build enquiry, and treating it like one wastes a round trip. Before sending it through the enquiry channel, gather the following:

  • Exact model and serial or drawing number of the parent equipment, plus the part number and position if known.
  • Material, standard or grade called for, and whether an equivalent or superseding part is acceptable.
  • Quantity needed now, plus any anticipated future requirement so that price breaks and lead times can be assessed together.
  • Required date, destination port and preferred shipping terms, separated from the technical request.
  • Documentation required: certificate of conformity, material traceability, test report or inspection record.
  • Warranty terms and the repair or return route if the part fails in service.

An enquiry that carries this information lets the supplier respond with a part reference, a price, a lead time and a documentation package in one step. It also creates a record that makes the next replacement faster, which is the whole point of treating spares as a managed system rather than a series of emergencies.

References

  1. Kian, R., Bektaş, T., & Ouelhadj, D. (2018). Optimal spare parts management for vessel maintenance scheduling. Annals of Operations Research, 272(1-2), 323-353. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-018-2907-y
  2. Patzke, M., Saeed, S., & Pahl, J. (2024). Critical spare parts management in maritime shipping: Selection and control. Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. https://doi.org/10.24251/hicss.2024.172
  3. Anglou, F.-Z., Ponis, S., & Spanos, A. (2021). A machine learning approach to enable bulk orders of critical spare-parts in the shipping industry. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management, 14(3), 604. https://doi.org/10.3926/jiem.3446
  4. Shin, Y., Thai, V., & Yuen, K. F. (2018). The impact of supply chain relationship quality on performance in the maritime logistics industry in light of firm characteristics. The International Journal of Logistics Management, 29(3), 1077-1097. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijlm-10-2016-0227
  5. Alipour, M., & Damavandi, M. (2011). The impact of e-procurement implementation on performance of ship management companies (case study of IRISL). In 2011 IEEE 3rd International Conference on Communication Software and Networks (pp. 618-622). https://doi.org/10.1109/iccsn.2011.6014969
  6. Prabhakar, V. J., & Sandborn, P. (2012). A part total cost of ownership model for long life cycle electronic systems. International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing, 25(4-5), 384-397. https://doi.org/10.1080/0951192x.2010.531293
  7. Centobelli, P., Cerchione, R., Maglietta, A., & Oropallo, E. (2023). Sailing through a digital and resilient shipbuilding supply chain: An empirical investigation. Journal of Business Research, 158, 113686. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2023.113686