1. Home
  2. News & Insights
  3. Beyond the Certificate: Human Factors in Life Jackets, Immersion Suits and Life Rafts

Industry note

Beyond the Certificate: Human Factors in Life Jackets, Immersion Suits and Life Rafts

Buying life-saving equipment is straightforward; specifying it so that it works on the night it is needed is not. A type-approval certificate answers a narrow and important question: has a representative sample of this device met a defined performance standard under defined test conditions? It does not answer the questions that decide survival, namely whether a particular person can get into the device quickly and correctly on a moving deck, and whether they can still function once inside it. The published evidence on donning time, thermal protection, training and workload is useful precisely because it treats equipment as one part of a human-equipment system rather than as a stand-alone product.

What the certificate establishes, and what it leaves open

Approval testing is designed to be repeatable, and so it uses controlled conditions and standardised procedures. Real abandonment is not repeatable. Reviewing immersion suit performance, Zhang and Song note that thermal behaviour depends on heat loss from the body but also on fit and sizing, garment design and test methods that are difficult to reproduce in a genuine open-sea scenario (Zhang and Song, 2013). The same logic runs across the category: the certificate is a floor, not a ceiling.

ItemWhat approval evidence typically addressesThe field question it leaves open
Life jacketBuoyancy, righting behaviour and other laboratory-measured characteristics of a sampleCan it be donned over heavy clothing, by this person, in this space, and does it stay secure through a wet and crowded evacuation?
Immersion suitInsulation and integrity under defined test conditionsDonning time and error rate across the real population; fit over work clothing; compatibility with the life jacket
Life raftStructure, inflation and the presence of an insulated floorHow much heat is lost once people and water are inside; how many occupants can manage themselves in it

Life raft insulation shows the gap clearly. Mak and colleagues, assessing a 16-person inflatable raft of a type used on passenger and commercial vessels, note that insulation requirements for raft components have historically been expressed without explicit performance criteria, and then measure what actually happens to occupants (Mak et al., 2008). The word insulated on a specification sheet is the beginning of a thermal calculation, not the end of one.

Donning time: the number that is not on the datasheet

The most concrete human-factors evidence concerns thermal protective immersion suits. Azizpour and colleagues ran donning trials with 108 participants, measuring both net donning time and donning correctness for suits with integrated buoyancy, in the context of the 120-second benchmark used for polar operations (Azizpour et al., 2023). The results are uncomfortable for anyone who assumes that approval equals readiness. Net donning time ranged from 65 to 341 seconds, and more than 90% of participants needed a total donning time above 120 seconds.

Mean donning time was not random. It rose by about 6.6% for every additional 10 years of age and was about 33% higher for female participants, and it fell by about 17% with prior experience. Two factors stand out for equipment buyers. Failing to remove shoes before donning increased mean time by roughly 26%, which is a stowage problem as much as a training one. Instruction method also mattered: video instruction was associated with a mean donning time about 21% longer than the alternative used in the study, but with fewer donning errors, about 1.5 on average against 2.3 for written instruction.

Faster is not automatically better if the suit then leaks or the hood is mis-seated; slower is not automatically safer if the water is rising. For procurement, the important finding is the spread: a device that one practised sailor can don in a minute may take another crew member several minutes, and the population of a passenger ship is not made up of practised sailors.

Correctness: a suit worn wrongly is not thermal protection

Azizpour and colleagues state the consequence directly: an incorrectly donned suit may fail to provide the thermal protection it was designed to deliver. Donning errors are not cosmetic. A badly seated face seal, an unfastened closure or a trapped hood defeats insulation and can speed water ingress, and the error data suggest that instruction format changes what people get wrong, not merely how quickly they move. Operators should therefore measure correctness as well as speed in drills, and treat the instruction sheet or video as part of the equipment package rather than an afterthought. Sizing is the other half of the problem: Zhang and Song identify fit and sizing as fundamental to thermal protection and highlight three-dimensional body scanning as a way to improve garment sizing (Zhang and Song, 2013). A size range that covers the nominal population on paper may still leave the smallest and largest wearers badly served.

Thermal protection is a system, not a garment

Immersion survival is a sequence of physiological events, and equipment has to intervene at each stage. Cold water triggers an immediate cold-shock response, including involuntary gasping, hyperventilation and a rise in heart rate, which is a drowning risk in the first minute before hypothermia has any chance to develop. Over the following minutes and hours, body heat is lost and physical and cognitive performance decline. The implication is that the whole envelope matters: the clothing worn underneath, the insulation and seal of the suit, the buoyancy aid, the raft, and whether the occupant is wet or dry inside it.

The life raft study is the clearest evidence that the envelope can undo the garment. Mak and colleagues tested a 16-person raft in mild cold conditions and reported that heat conductance decreased considerably as the raft floor was inflated, with a broadly similar insulation benefit at 50% and 100% floor inflation (Mak et al., 2008). They also note that a layer of water on the raft floor, likely when people climb in from the sea or when spray comes aboard, drastically increases heat loss for occupants wearing little protective clothing. Wave height, by contrast, could be ignored as a first approximation in their analysis. A raft certified as insulated can therefore still be a cold, wet place to wait, and the condition of the floor and the amount of water inside are operational variables rather than manufacturing ones.

Zhang and Song add the opposite thermal risk: pilots and helicopter rescuers wearing immersion suits in normal or hot conditions can experience thermal stress (Zhang and Song, 2013). Tolerance is not a soft criterion, because it determines whether a wearer keeps the equipment on and keeps working.

Compliance and training are separate levers

Two studies from different contexts make the same structural point. Bugeja and colleagues evaluated Victoria, Australia's 2005 compulsory personal flotation device (PFD) wearing regulations using coronial data on recreational boating deaths. Deaths fell from 59 in the six pre-regulation years to 16 in the five post-regulation years, a statistically significant decrease, with reductions across several age groups and vessel types (Bugeja et al., 2014). As a retrospective before-and-after study it shows association rather than proof of a single cause, but the direction is consistent with regulation changing behaviour at population scale.

Oporia and colleagues ran a two-arm cluster randomised controlled trial at 14 landing sites on Lake Albert, Uganda, testing a six-month peer-to-peer training programme for occupational boaters (Oporia et al., 2023). Self-reported lifejacket wear rose from 30.8% to 65.1% in the intervention arm, against 29.9% to 43.2% in the control arm; observed wear rose from 1.0% to 26.8%, against 0.6% to 8.8%. The adjusted prevalence ratio for self-reported wear among trained boaters was 1.78, with a 95% confidence interval of 1.38 to 2.30. The intervention worked, yet observed wear after training was still only about a quarter of boaters, and the gap between what people said and what observers saw is itself a finding. Self-reported compliance is not evidence of compliance.

Working while encumbered: rescue is part of the requirement

Survival equipment is not only for the person wearing it, because crew may have to give rescue breathing, first aid or manual help while wearing a suit and vest. Venema and colleagues randomised 65 lifeboat crew members to perform single-rescuer basic life support on a mannequin in either their protective gear or civilian clothes, five two-minute sessions each, on dry land (Venema et al., 2021). The gear did not significantly impair basic life support quality and did not significantly increase perceived exertion. But compression depth, compression frequency, the proportion of correct compressions, leaning on the thorax and ventilation volumes were suboptimal in both groups.

The measured conclusion is reassuring about the gear and sobering about baseline skill, and it is a caution against over-reading a controlled trial: dry land, a stable surface and a mannequin are not a lifeboat in a seaway, and the authors note that real-world impact needs further study. For drills, the practical reading is that equipment and skill should be practised together, in the conditions where they will be used.

What to check before specifying or accepting equipment

The evidence converts into checks that can be written into a specification or an acceptance conversation.

  • Sizing range. Ask which population the range is designed to fit, including small adults and children where relevant, and how fit is verified.
  • Donning data and instructions. Request donning demonstrations or trial data rather than certificates alone; review whether instructions are written, pictorial or video, and note that speed and correctness trade off.
  • Stowage for fast donning. Pre-donation, accessible stowage, lighting and a place to sit or brace all reduce time, and shoe removal should be designed for rather than improvised.
  • Visibility and retrofit. Lights and retro-reflective material should be fit for purpose and maintainable over the life of the equipment.
  • Compatibility. Check the immersion suit and life jacket as a pair, because donning order, closure access and buoyancy distribution change when they are worn together.
  • Raft habitability. Insulated floor condition, water management inside the raft and how many occupants can help themselves are operational questions worth asking.
  • Maintenance and training regime. Inspection intervals, replacement criteria and drill realism matter as much as initial approval, and observed performance should be recorded rather than attendance.

Because these items work as a system, they should be specified as one. A buyer comparing life jackets, immersion suits and life rafts is choosing a combination that has to survive contact with frightened people in bad weather, so the supporting documentation on sizing, instructions, maintenance and training belongs in the comparison alongside the hardware. Within the safety equipment category, treating that documentation as part of the product is the difference between buying equipment that is approved and equipment that is likely to be effective.

References

  1. Azizpour, H., Galea, E. R., Erland, S., Batalden, B.-M., Deere, S., & Oltedal, H. (2023). Factors influencing the time required to don thermal protective immersion suits correctly. Safety Science, 164, 106064. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssci.2023.106064
  2. Bugeja, L., Cassell, E., Brodie, L. R., & Walter, S. J. (2014). Effectiveness of the 2005 compulsory personal flotation device (PFD) wearing regulations in reducing drowning deaths among recreational boaters in Victoria, Australia. Injury Prevention, 20(6), 387-392. https://doi.org/10.1136/injuryprev-2014-041169
  3. Mak, L., Kuczora, A., DuCharme, M. B., Boone, J., Brown, R., Farnworth, B., Evely, K.-A., Basset, F. A., & MacKinnon, S. (2008). Assessment of thermal protection of life rafts in passenger vessel abandonment situations. Volume 2: Structures, Safety and Reliability (ASME OMAE), 389-398. https://doi.org/10.1115/omae2008-57398
  4. Oporia, F., Kibira, S. P. S., Jagnoor, J., Kobusingye, O., Makumbi, F. E., Isunju, J. B., & Nuwaha, F. (2023). Peer-led training improves lifejacket wear among occupational boaters: Evidence from a cluster randomized controlled trial on Lake Albert, Uganda. PLOS ONE, 18(10), e0292754. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0292754
  5. Venema, A. M., Sahinovic, M. M., Ramaker, A. J. D. W. R., van de Riet, Y. N., Absalom, A. R., & Wietasch, J. K. G. (2021). Performance of basic life support by lifeboat crewmembers while wearing a survival suit and life vest: A randomized controlled trial. Frontiers in Public Health, 9, 666553. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2021.666553
  6. Zhang, H., & Song, G. (2013). Performance of immersion suits: A literature review. Journal of Industrial Textiles, 44(2), 288-306. https://doi.org/10.1177/1528083713486823